"Dialogue Central": Complete Listing of Internet Theological Dialogues by Dave Armstrong (Part 2: Non-Protestants)

Go to Part One of this Index for the following (Protestant) categories:

PROTESTANTS

Anglicans
Baptists (Including Reformed [Calvinist] Baptists)
Church of Christ
Evangelicals
Liberal / "Progressive"
Lutherans
Methodists
Reformed (Calvinist) / Presbyterians

* * * * *

ORTHODOX (EASTERN)

Fr. Ambrose

Is Purgatory a "Place"?: Misconceptions From Fr. Ambrose About My Opinion (and the Church's View) / Also: Development and Alleged Historical Revisionism

Anonymous

Mary, the Immaculate Conception, and Original Sin, Jesus and "Immortality", Nestorianism, and Orthodox-Catholic Differences (Christological Controversies)

Dialogue: Annulment vs. Divorce

Multiple

Discussion on Orthodox Caesaropapism and Proper Historiography (vs. "Theophan" and Joel Kalvesmaki)

Perry Robinson

Response to an Orthodox Critic Concerning My Supposed Ignorance of Orthodoxy and Illegitimate Apologetic Methodology

Frank Schaeffer

Frank Schaeffer, Son of the Evangelical Icon Francis Schaeffer, Has Become "Pro Choice" and Blames Pro-Lifers For George Tiller's Murder

CATHOLICS

Orthodox Catholics

Anonymous

Baby --- Bathwater: Don't Ditch Lay Apologetics Altogether Because of Imperfect Lay Apologists

Ecumenism, Evangelism and Apologetics, and No Salvation Outside the Church: Thoughts on the Relationship Between Them

On the Nature of Idolatry and Whether it Resides Primarily in the Heart

Jesus' Human Nature, The Immaculate Conception of Mary, the Virgin Birth, and Original Sin: Reflections on Their Relationship to Each Other


Dialogue on Different Aspects of Purgatory and its Relation to Baptism and Penance

Merit: Clarification of the Catholic Doctrine (Condign and Congruous Merit, Total Depravity, Prevenient Grace, Etc.)

"Breier"

Dialogue on Whether Ecumenism is Worthwhile and Necessary and Contrary to Apologetics and Evangelization

Mike Breslin

Catholic Debate on the Catholic Charismatic Renewal

Eric G.

Dialogue on the Galileo Fiasco and Plea for Better Understanding of the Church's Error, Given the State of Scientific and Astronomical Knowledge in 1633

Why the Galileo Case Doesn't Disprove Catholic Infallibility, Rightly-Understood / Sola Scriptura Redux (vs. Ken Temple and Eric G.)

Stephen Hand

Debate on Whether the Confederate Flag is the Moral and Cultural Equivalent of the Nazi Swastika

"JS" (Thomist)

Dialogue on Molinism (Speculations on How God Predestines)


Dialogue on Molinism and God's Mode of Predestination (+ Part II | Part III | Part IV)

Jonathan

Reply to Questions About Catholic Mariology (and the Rosary) From a Recent Convert

John Lowell

Irrational, Uncharitable, Groundless Smear Campaign Against Scott Hahn and Lay Apologetics and Evangelism Continues

 

On Irrational Hostility to Catholic Conversion Stories (Particularly Scott Hahn's)

Multiple

Dialogue With Priests on Extraordinary Ministers of Holy Communion

Ruminations on Christian Idealism and Objective Thought vs. Subjectivism, Visual Impressions, and Image in Society

"Nordskoven"

Does Mary's Role as Mediatrix Contradict Jesus Christ as the Sole Mediator? / Response to a Catholic Critic

Dr. Alexander Pruss (philosophy professor)

A Dialogue on the Nature of God's Foreknowledge and Sovereignty

Rory

Dialogue With a Catholic on the Perspicuity (Clearness) of Scripture, and the Definition of Christian in Relation to the Holy Trinity (+ Part Two)

David Schütz

Reply to Catholic Semi-Critical Comments on My Luther Research

Liberal, Dissident Catholics

Anonymous

Dialogue on the Documentary Theory of Biblical Authorship (JEPD) and of Dissenting Liberal Hermeneutics Generally

Joe

Challenges For Self-Described "Progressive / Liberal Catholic" Joe ("jcecil3")

Fr. Joseph S. O'Leary

Case Study in Liberal Catholic Dissent: Fr. Joseph S. O'Leary

Graham Yearley

The One-Minute Apologist Trashed Along With Scott Hahn's Reasons to Believe / Negative Review of The Catholic Verses

"Traditionalist" Catholics (Self-Defined)

Anonymous

My Luther Book Blasted For Being Far Too Kind and Charitable to Luther / Pre-Vatican II Popes' Use of the Description "Separated Brethren"

Dialogue: Baptism, the Mystical Body of Christ, and Implications for Ecumenism

Dialogue: Vatican II and Other Religions (Nostra Aetate)

On Supposed Deficiencies in My Treatment of Radical Catholic "Traditionalists"

"Boniface"

Reply to Traditionalist Catholic "Boniface's" Article: "Converts and Traditionalism"

Mark Cameron

Critique of my Syllabus of 60 "Traditionalist" Errors and My Counter-Reply

Dialogue on The Remnant ("Traditionalist" Group)

Mario Derksen (later became a sedevacantist)

Are All Catholic Laymen and Non-Theologians Qualified to Freely and Frequently Criticize the Pope's Opinions and Prudential Judgment?

Dan Hunter

Are Vatican II and the "New Mass" Counter-Influences to Orthodoxy and Traditional Liturgy, in Terms of Drawing in Converts to the Catholic Faith?

Leo

Leo the Lion Roars Against Hapless Non-"Traditionalist" (Me!)

Multiple

Vatican II: Is it Orthodox and Binding? / The Infallibility and Sublime Authority of Conciliar and Papal Decrees / Different Levels of Church Authority

Pope John Paul II and the Koran-Kissing Incident: Summary and Analysis of the Incoherence of the Horrified "Traditionalist" Objection (vs. John Phillips, and others)

Dialogue: Catholic "Traditionalism": the Dreadful Malady of the Mind and Scourge of an Optimistic Faith in God's Protection of His Church (vs. David Palm and Mario Derksen)

Pathetic "Traditionalist" Feeding Frenzy Over My Defense of Venerable Pope John Paul II Kissing the Koran / "Calumny in the Blogosphere" (Fr. Orsi)

David Palm

Counter-"Traditionalist" Argument From Liturgical Development: Method of Receiving Holy Communion

Dialogue: Should the Pope Kiss The Koran?: Ecumenism as an Effort to Acknowledge Partial Truth Wherever it is Found

The Remnant

Critique of The Remnant, with Copious Documentation (vs. John Vennari, Michael J. Matt, etc.)

Seattle Catholic
 

"Traditionalist" Errors of the Seattle Catholic Documented

Robert Sungenis

Exchanges With Robert Sungenis on Geocentrism and Perceived Personal Attacks

Can God Change His Mind?: Dialogue With Bob Sungenis on God's Immutability, Omniscience, Atemporality, Simplicity, and Impassibility (Divine Emotions?)

Robert Sungenis' Responses to Recent Critiques on This Blog Regarding God's Characteristics and Geocentrism (With My Replies)

John F. Triolo

On the Tridentine Mass, Unnecessary Related Divisions, and Pope Benedict XVI's New Directives Regarding Same

HERESIES AND COMPARATIVE RELIGION

Islam

Reply to a Muslim Apologist Concerning the Two Natures of Christ and Trinitarianism (vs. Shabir Ally)

Jehovah's Witnesses

Dialogue with a Jehovah's Witness on the Deity of Christ and Trinitarianism: Direct Statements of Jesus' Equality With God the Father: Jesus Own Words (+ Part Two)

Judaism

Ari G. (Orthodox)

Jewish-Christian Dialogue: Is the Servant of Isaiah 53 the Messiah or Collective Israel?

Jewish-Christian Dialogue on Authority and the Rabbinic Credentials of Jesus and the Apostle Paul

Mormonism

Dr. Barry R. Bickmore

Dialogue With A Mormon Apologist on the Christian Doctrine of God, and Doctrinal Development (+ Part Two)

Tom

Dialogue With a Mormon on Whether the Father and the Son are of the Same Essence and Nature, and on the Transcendence of God

SEXUAL AND LIFE ISSUES

Dialogue on the Ethical Distinction Between Artificial Contraception and Natural Family Planning (NFP) (vs. a Catholic woman)

Dialogue: Is Premarital Sex Wrong? (vs. C. Jack Elliott)

Premarital Sex: Does St. Paul Permit and Sanction It in 1 Corinthians 7:36? (vs. Scott Nemeth)

Discussions About Christian Sexual Morality and Marriage With Atheists / Massive Sociological Evidence Bolsters Christian Moral Positions (multiple atheists and agnostics)

Dialogue: Why Did God Kill Onan? Why is Contraception Condemned by the Catholic Church? (vs. self-described "liberal" Catholic)

Dialogue on Contraception (vs. multiple opponents: Orthodox, Anglican, and evangelical Protestant)

Dialogue on Contraception and Natural Family Planning (NFP) (vs. "Grubb": Reformed Baptist)

Dialogue on "Ethical" Legal Abortion and the Philosophical Criteria Pertaining to Whether Personhood Begins at Conception (vs. Sogn Mill-Scout)

Dialogue on the "Hard Cases" of Abortion (Particularly Rape) (vs. Sogn Mill-Scout)

Dialogue on Homosexuality (vs. Sogn Mill-Scout)

Dialogue With an Atheist on Homosexuality (vs. "drunkentune")

Dialogue With a Homosexual

Dialogue With a Bisexual Agnostic on Homosexuality (+ Part II, which includes very extensive medical/scientific data)

Dialogue With a Bisexual Agnostic on Homosexuality, Round Two

ETHICAL, SOCIAL, POLITICAL, MISC. ISSUES

Dialogue With an African-American on Rev. Wright and Racism (Including In-Depth Biblical Examinations of Complete Sermons and Speeches on Judgment)

 

Explaining the Distinction Between Gender Differentiation in a Paradigm of Equality and Woman-Hating Chauvinism, to a Radical Feminist (vs. "Nenya")

Reply to an Intellectually Cogent and Coherent, Nuanced (Indeed, Irrefutable) Feminist Critique (vs. "bellatrys")

Dialogue on the Ethics of, and Biblical Support for, Vegetarianism (+ Parts Two / Three) (vs. Sogn Mill-Scout)

Jesus, Vegetarianism, Bambi, and Us (vs. Keith Akers)

Debate on the War in Iraq (vs. "Secret Agent Man")

Is It Dissent Against the Pope and the Church, and Downright Disobedient For a Catholic to Favor the War in Iraq? (multiple opponents)

Dialogue on Christian Pacifism and "Just War": Biblical and Social Factors (vs. Edward Hamilton)

Dialogue on the Iraqi War: Is it in Accordance With Just War Criteria or an Imperialistic Outrage? (+ Part Two) (vs. Stephen Hand)

Critique of Dr. Thomas Sowell's Article: "Trashing our History; Hiroshima" (vs. Dr. Thomas Sowell)

Dialogue With an African-American on Racism, Liberalism, and Affirmative Action

ATHEISTS AND AGNOSTICS

Dave Van Allen

Reply to Deconversion Story of Dave Van Allen, Webmaster of ExChristian.Net

Anonymous

Replies to Some Skeptical Objections to the Christian Doctrine of Hell ("Religion Is Lies" website)

Dr. Jim Arvo

Dialogue with Former Christian, Dr. Jim Arvo, on Various Aspects of "Deconversion"

Edward Babinski

Debate With an Agnostic on the Meaning of "Last Days" and Whether the Author of Hebrews Was a False Prophet

Critique of Agnostic Ed Babinski's Post: "The Problem of Evil, Alvin Plantinga and Victor Reppert" (the "Emotional" Argument From Evil)

Objections to Some Atheist / Agnostic "Proof Texts" of an Alleged Flat-Earth Biblical Cosmology

Round III With Ed Babinski On Profound Christian Ignorance, and Every Subject Under the Sun Except the Topic (The Psalms)

How and Why Discussions With Agnostics and Atheists Often (Sadly) Collapse / The Many Logical Fallacies of Ed Babinski and Friends (Was [and occasionally still touches upon]: Discussion on the Psalms) (vs. Ed Babinski and Pals)

Postscript to Dialogue With Agnostic Ed Babinski on the Psalms, Etc.: Ed's Attempt to Enlist an Ancient Near East Scholar in Support Backfires (Dr. James Roger Black vs. Ed Babinski; compiled and additional commentary by Dave Armstrong)

Is the Bible Silent or Lax on Abortion? Hardly. But Agnostic Ed Babinski Gives it His Best Shot in Arguing Just That

Second Reply to Agnostic Ed Babinski on the Supposed Irrationality and Immorality of the Psalms and the Christian Worldview

Reply to "The Problem of Pain and the Egomania of the Psalms"

Friendly Discussion on Presuppositions and Basic Differences (Particularly, Hell), With an Agnostic

S. Burgener

Supposed Contradiction Between 2 Samuel 24 and 1 Chronicles 21 (God or Satan as Cause?)

Steve Conifer

Dialogue With an Atheist on Logical Positivism and the Existence and Cause (or No Cause) of the Universe

Dialogue With Atheists on the Evolution of the Eye, Irreducible Complexity, and Intelligent Design

Dialogue With an Atheist on the Premises and Axioms of Atheism

Dr. Jerry Coyne

Reply to Atheist Scientist Jerry Coyne's Position That Science and Religion Are Utterly Incompatible: Rationally Disallowing Even Theistic Evolutionism

"DagoodS"

On the Alleged Contradictions of 2 Samuel 24, and 1 Chronicles 21 and 27

Did God Harden Pharaoh's Heart? (Does God Positively Ordain Evil?)

Alleged Contradictions Regarding the Twelve Disciples of Jesus

Supposed Contradictions in the Gospel Accounts of Jesus' Calling of the Disciples

 

Discussion With Atheists on Hell, the Argument From Desire, and God's Justice and Ours (vs. "DagoodS" and others) (+ Part Two)

"DagoodS" Deconversion Story, Part I: Projection, Open-Mindedness, and Presuppositional Issues

Critique of "DagoodS"' Deconversion Story Meets a Sudden Premature Death

Atheists' Unreasonable, Unrealistic Demands For Proof of God's Existence (Massive Miracles, Etc.)

Dialogue With Atheists on a Supposedly Sexist, Misogynist Bible and Christianity, and on Female Atheist Disdain for Christian Women as Abused "Sheep" [+ others as well]

Dialogue With an Atheist About How Much He Actually Knew About Biblical Exegesis as a Christian (Especially, Abortion in the Bible)

Dialogue With an Atheist About Miracles and the Influence of First Premises on One's Methodology and Openness to Evidences and Proofs

Further Exchanges With Atheist DagoodS About First Premises, the Place of Evidence, My Annoying Socratic Methodology and Supposed Inconsistencies, Etc.

Joseph of Arimathea: Atheist "DagoodS" Fallaciously Asserts Alleged Biblical "Contradictions" (Lousy Atheist Exegesis Example #5672)

The Hittites: Atheist "DagoodS" Lies About Christian Apologists Supposedly Lying About How Biblical Critics Once Doubted Their Historical Existence

Habitually "Lying" Christian Apologists?: 19th Century "Hittites Didn't Exist" Radical Skepticism and Examination of Atheist DagoodS' Replies and Charges

Hittite Skeptics Chronicles, Part III: Specific Citations of Denial (Budge, Sumner, and Conder) and Biblical Historical Accuracy (in the Time of Elisha)

Great Hittite Wars, Part IV: Lying Christian Egyptologist M. G. Kyle?: Atheist DagoodS Disputes Sir A. E. Wallis Budge's Reported Hittite Skepticism

Resurrection Appearance Accounts: More "Bible Butchery" From Atheist "DagoodS": His Demonstrably False Pretense That the Passages Are Contradictory

Dr. Ted Drange (philosophy professor)

Refutation of Atheists' Alleged Biblical "Contradictions" Concerning Salvation and Supposed Annihilationism and Universalism

Dialogue With an Atheist Philosophy Professor on the Kalam Cosmological Argument for God's Existence and its Possible Alternatives (+ Part Two)

Preliminary Replies to Atheists' Questions About Christianity (Particularly the Trinity and Salvation)

Dialogue on the Argument From Non-Belief (ANB) as a Proposed Disproof of God's Existence (vs. Steve Conifer and Dr. Ted Drange)

"drunkentune"

Dialogue #2 With an Atheist on the Problem of Evil

Old Habits Die Hard: The Garden Variety Atheist Fairy Tale of "Christianity vs. Science and Reason" Redux

On Whether Atheism is Inherently More Rational and Scientific, and Less Dogmatic and Axiomatic Than Christianity

How Atheists and Christians Can Constructively Dialogue, With Mutual Respect (+ Related Censorship, Free Speech, Ethics and "Legalism" Issues) (vs. "drunkentune" and others)

Matt Fahrner

Dialogue With an Agnostic Concerning Several Common Objections to Christianity in General and Catholicism in Particular

Theresa Frasch

Response to the "Deconversion Story" of a Pastor's Wife

Matthew Green

Dialogue on Biblical Cosmology, Round One

Mike Hardie

Dialogue With an Atheist on the "Problem of Good" and the Nature of Meaningfulness in Atheism (+ Part Two) (The Flip Side of the Problem of Evil Argument Against Christianity)

Joe E. Holman

Critique of Some Key Fallacies in Atheist Joe E. Holman's Deconversion Story

Bob Hypes

Reply to Bob Hypes' Article: "Religion and How I Lost It"

Bob Hypes' Reply to My Critique of His Article: Religion and How I Lost It and My Counter-Reply

Jon

Dialogue With an Agnostic on the Galileo Fiasco and Whether or Not it Disproves Catholic Infallibility or Suggests Various Other Shortcomings (vs. Jon)

Charlie Kluepfel

Dialogue With a Skeptic of Christianity

John W. Loftus

Is God in Time?


Serious Christian Treatments of the Problem of Evil and Breezy Atheist Dismissals of Them Sans Rational Argument

Dialogue #3 With an Atheist on the Problem of Evil

Reply to Former Christian John Loftus' "Outsider Test of Faith" Series 

The Essential Silliness and Hypocrisy (Even Duplicity) of Atheist John Loftus: Webmaster of Debunking Christianity

"Jittery John" Loftus Again Throws a Hissy-Fit When I Simply Critique His Argument Against the Biblical, Timeless, Transcendent God 

Critique of John W. Loftus' "Deconversion" Story From Church of Christ Pastor to Atheist

Atheist John W. Loftus and His "Deconversion" Story: The Strange Saga Continues and the Plot Thickens

Census and Jesus' Birth in Bethlehem: Atheist John W. Loftus' Irrational and Uninformed Criticisms of the Biblical Accounts

John W. Loftus: "Blood Out of a Turnip": Getting Nowhere Trying to Persuade an Active Atheist Polemicist to Defend His Own Positions Against Critique

RubySera Martin

Now I Am a "Spiritual Predator" Who Wants to "Attack, Maim, and Torture" Because I Dared to Critique an Atheist Deconversion [John Loftus]

Daniel Morgan

Dialogue With an Atheist on the "Basics": Creation, Freedom, Rebellion, Suffering, Etc.

Stacked Deck: Losing One's Christian Faith in College / General Epistemological Discussion With an Atheist

Multiple

Reply to Alleged Biblical Contradictions Concerning Judas and His Death

Dialogue on Materialist Evolutionary Theory and Intelligent Design (including an examination of St. Augustine's and St. Thomas Aquinas's Views on Creation and Evolution)

Short Dialogue With Two Atheists on Souls, Bodily Resurrection, and Heaven

Discussions About Christian Sexual Morality and Marriage With Atheists / Massive Sociological Evidence Bolsters Christian Moral Positions (vs. John W. Loftus and four others)

Some Christian Replies to the Problem of Evil as Set Forth by Atheists (vs. "drunken tune" and John W. Loftus)

Reply to Alleged Biblical Contradictions Concerning Judas and His Death (vs. Dave Van Allen and Dr. Jim Arvo)

Angry, Irrational Atheists and Other Ex-Christians On the Prowl Again: Christopher Hitchens vs. Fr. George Rutler / The Good Folks at ExChristian.Net

paul

Reply to a Skeptic Regarding Elijah the Prophet's Extraordinary Departure From Earth and Relation to John the Baptist

 

Dialogue With a Skeptic Regarding Elijah and John the Baptist, Round Two

"ProfMTH" / Mitch

Reply to Atheist Mitch / "ProfMTH"'s Video "Jesus Was Not the Messiah" - Pt. I (Alleged "Fabrications" and "Misquotations" of OT Messianic Prophecies)

Second Reply to Atheist Mitch / "ProfMTH" Regarding Christian Apologists' Allegedly Dishonest Interpretation of the Messianic Prophecy, Isaiah 53

Third Reply to Mitch / "ProfMTH" (Video: "Jesus Was Not the Messiah, Part 3: Crucifixion Prophecies") / Zechariah 13:6 and Psalm 22

Reply to Atheist Mitch / "ProfMTH" on Whether John 7:38 is a Legitimate Reference to Old Testament Scripture

Reply to Atheist "ProfMTH" / Bart Ehrman Video, "The 'Real' Paul": Is the Biblical Paul Self-Contradictory? (Pagan Ignorance vs. Deliberate Unbelief)

Dr. Jan Schreurs

Dialogue on the Ethical Implications of the Story of Abraham and Isaac

Dialogue With an Agnostic Concerning Relativist vs. Absolutist Morality and the Natural Law

Dialogue With an Agnostic on the "Logic of God," Science, Axioms, and Biases

Sue Strandberg

Dialogue With an Atheist on the Relationship of Christianity and Metaphysics to the Scientific Method

Dialogue With an Atheist on the Epistemology of Disbelief in God and the "Demonization" of Opponents (Including Appendices on Conscience and Disproofs of Worldviews)

Go to Part One of this Index for the following (Protestant) categories:

PROTESTANTS

Anglicans
Baptists (Including Reformed [Calvinist] Baptists)
Church of Christ
Evangelicals
Liberal / "Progressive"
Lutherans
Methodists
Reformed (Calvinist) / Presbyterians


Last updated on 30 June 2011