Wednesday, November 28, 2007

The False Doctrine of "Soul Sleep" and Prayers To, For, and From the Dead: the Biblical Evidence Confirms Catholic Belief

A member on the CHNI discussion forums, Brian, asked some good, probing questions. His words will be in blue.

* * * * *

Hi Brian,

Man, you are a question machine! But that's good: inquisitive minds will find the truth if they sincerely seek it and (most importantly) are willing to submit to it when they find it.

I ran into this objection on another bulletin board:
"In Mat 27:52 it describes those who arose from their graves when Jesus rose as "those who slept". Paul uses the same description in 1 Cr 15:20. Paul in 1 Th 4 compares the living with those who were put to sleep, i.e. the dead.
This is an instance of what is called "phenomenological" language: the language of outward description or appearance rather than complete metaphysical analysis. So to us the dead appear to be asleep.

Paul tells the Thessalonians that when the Lord descends from heaven, those sleeping (believers) will arise and along with the living (believers) shall meet the Lord in the air (between heaven and earth). The believers who were dead were clearly not in heaven or hell or all of 1 Th 4: 13-18 makes no sense whatsoever."

Of course, the question arises: where does this person think they were? Catholics have no problem interpreting this. There is, as David mentioned, the Limbo of the Fathers (or Hebrew: Sheol / Greek: Hades) or purgatory. These can all be amply defended from Holy Scripture.

The question I have is how does this resolve with for instance the ideas in revelation of the saints and martyrs praying, or of Jesus seeing Moses and Elijah on Mt. Tabor. Or the passage that says to be absent from the body is to be present with the Lord?

Consciousness after death is clearly taught in Scripture. For example: the soul is described as a separate entity from the body:
MATTHEW 10:28 And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.

REVELATION 6:9-10 And when he had opened the fifth seal, I saw under the altar the souls of them that were slain for the word of God, and for the testimony which they held: And they cried with a loud voice, saying, How long, O Lord, holy and true, dost thou not judge and avenge our blood on them that dwell on the earth?

1 KINGS 17:21-22 Then he stretched himself upon the child three times, and cried to the Lord, "O Lord my God, let this child's soul come into him again." And the Lord hearkened to the voice of Elijah; and the soul of the child came into him again, and he revived. (cf. Lk 8:53-55)

* * * * *

JOHN 11:26 And whosoever liveth and believeth in me shall never die. Believest thou this?
Jesus clearly sets forth the notion that the faithful Christian will always have conscious, unending existence with God. He cannot possibly be referring to physical death, since all men die in that sense.
PSALM 116:15 Precious in the sight of the LORD is the death of his saints.
The consciousness of the dead is assumed or else the verse becomes ludicrous.

1 SAMUEL 28:11-16 tells us that Samuel returns from the dead and pronounces Saul's death sentence.

Jehovah's Witnesses, Seventh-Day Adventists and other sects and cults that teach what is known as annihilationism or soul-sleep (no consciousness after death and no hell, with the sinner being annihilated out of existence altogether) typically rely on the distortion of a few passages in order to "prove" their error:
Ecclesiastes 9:5: . . . the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward . . .
If the first clause is understood in an absolute sense, then so must the second clause be interpreted. Thus, the dead would have no "reward" as well as no consciousness. This would deny the resurrection and the rewarding of the righteous (see Rev 20:11-13, 21:6-7, 22:12,14). Obviously, then, a qualification of some sort has to be placed on Ecc 9:5. In the very next verse, we learn that:
. . . neither have they any more a portion for ever in any thing that is done under the sun.
In other words, in relation to this world, the dead know nothing, but they are in a different realm, where they do know something. As further examples of this limited sense of "not knowing anything" in Scripture, see 1 Sam 20:39 and 2 Sam 15:11, where an interpretation of unconsciousness would be ridiculous.
Ezekiel 18:4 (also 18:20): . . . the soul that sinneth, it shall die.
Here, the spiritual use of "death" in the Bible is overlooked. For instance, 1 Timothy 5:6 reads:
But she that liveth in pleasure is dead while she liveth. (cf. Eph 2:1 and Lk 15:24)
That Ezekiel 18:4,20 refers to spiritual death (i.e., separation from God, not annihilation) is obvious from context, since 18:21 declares:
But if the wicked will turn from all his sins that he hath committed, and keep all my statutes, and do that which is lawful and right, he shall surely live, he shall not die.
Since all men die physically, this must be talking about the spiritual, or "second" death. So much for this "proof" . . .
Psalm 146:4: His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.
This verse's meaning is similar to that of Ecclesiastes 9:5. Here, "thoughts" refer to "unaccomplished purposes" of a person on earth. Death puts an end to those purposes, as anyone would agree. In this sense, one's thoughts "perish" at death. Another similar use occurs at Isaiah 55:7:
Let the wicked forsake his way, and the unrighteousness man his thoughts . . .
This doesn't mean that unrighteous men must cease all thinking and become unconscious and nonexistent. Nor does Ps 146:4. Much of this sort of inadequate and erroneous exegesis results from a profound lack of understanding of the many literary forms and devices used in Scripture, as seen in these three examples. Much of the OT is poetry of one sort or another. One cannot interpret poetry in a wooden, literal way.

And of course the crucial question is, what does the Bible mean to say or not regarding our state after earth? How can we ask saints to pray for us if according to the Thessalonians passage they are actually asleep?

Even Martin Luther and John Calvin admitted that the saints may be praying for us in heaven:
Although angels in heaven pray for us . . . saints on earth, and perhaps also in heaven, do likewise, . . .

(Smalcald Articles, 1537, Part II, Article II in Theodore G. Tappert, translator, The Book of Concord, St. Louis: Concordia Pub. House, 1959, 297)

I grant they pray for us in this way.

(Institutes of the Christian Religion, III, 20, 24)
Luther and his successor as head of Lutheranism, Philip Melanchthon, also accepted the validity of prayers for the dead:
As for the dead, since Scripture gives us no information on the subject, I regard it as no sin to pray with free devotion in this or some similar fashion: "Dear God, if this soul is in a condition accessible to mercy, be thou gracious to it."

(Confession Concerning Christ's Supper, 1528, in Luther's Works, edited by Jaroslav Pelikan, vol. 37, 369)

[W]e know that the ancients speak of prayer for the dead, which we do not prohibit . . .

(Apology to the Augsburg Confession: Article XXIV, 94)
The Apostle Paul prayed for the dead:
2 Timothy 1:16-18 May the Lord grant mercy to the household of Onesiphorus, for he often refreshed me; he was not ashamed of my chains, but when he arrived in Rome he searched for me eagerly and found me - may the Lord grant him to find mercy from the Lord on that Day - and you well know all the service he rendered at Ephesus.
This passage gives Protestants fits. Protestants can't accept the practice of praying for the dead because of their theology; therefore, they must explain this away somehow. What they do is either deny that Onesiphorus is dead, or that Paul is praying. Most of the nine Protestant commentaries I consulted for this passage admit that he was praying, but deny that the person was dead. Some try to say that Paul was merely "wishing", but I don't see any difference between that and a prayer: it looks like a word game to avoid the implications. The same commentaries said he was possibly dead (two), take no position (two), think he was "probably not" dead (one), or deny it (three). A.T. Robertson, the great Baptist Greek scholar, felt that he was "apparently" dead and that Paul was "wishing" rather than praying. I think it's much more plausible to simply take the Catholic position: the man died and Paul was praying for him.

As for saints praying for us: if these saints are alive, aware of earthly events, and pray for us (because they possess love and concern), then it is not wrong to ask them to pray for us. How do we know they are aware? Because of Hebrews 12:1: ". . . we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses . . ."

Word Studies in the New Testament
(Marvin R. Vincent, Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 1980; originally 1887; Vol. 4, p. 536), a famous, standard Protestant reference work, comments on this verse as follows:
'Witnesses' does not mean spectators [Greek martus, from which is derived martyr], but those who have borne witness to the truth, as those enumerated in chapter 11. Yet the idea of spectators is implied, and is really the principal idea. The writer's picture is that of an arena in which the Christians whom he addresses are contending in a race, while the vast host of the heroes of faith who, after having borne witness to the truth, have entered into their heavenly rest, watches the contest from the encircling tiers of the arena, compassing and overhanging it like a cloud, filled with lively interest and sympathy, and lending heavenly aid.
Saints in heaven are therefore aware of, and observe events on earth, "with lively interest," as Vincent puts it. Also:
Revelation 6:9-10 . . . I saw under the altar the souls of those who had been slain for the word of God and for the witness they had borne; they cried out with a loud voice, "O Sovereign Lord, holy and true, how long before thou wilt judge and avenge our blood on those who dwell upon the earth?"
Here the martyrs in heaven are saying what are known as "imprecatory prayers": pleas for God to rescue and vindicate the righteous. Examples can be found particularly in the Psalms (Psalms 35,59,69,79,109,139) and in Jeremiah (11:18 ff., 15:15 ff., 18:19 ff., 20:11 ff.). An angel offers up a very similar prayer in Zechariah 1:12. Jesus mentions a type of this prayer in Matthew 26:53, in which He stated that He could "pray" to the Father and receive legions of angels to prevent His arrest had it been the Father's will.

Therefore dead saints are praying for Christians on earth. If they can intercede for us, then why shouldn't we ask for their prayers? Clearly, they're aware of what is happening on earth. They are more alive, unfathomably more righteous, and obviously closer to God than we are. Omniscience isn't required for them to hear our prayers, as is often charged. Rather, we have reason to believe that they are out of time, by God's power, because to be in eternity is to be outside of the realm of time. That allows them to answer many requests for prayer because they have an infinite amount of "time" to do it.

How can they also be in heaven and hearing us?

Because God gives them that power, and because heaven is another dimension. The saints are out of time with God, and thus have all the "time" they need to listen to our petitions.

Do we argue that perhaps their bodies lie asleep as they await resurrection while their soul or spirit is in heaven and doing God's will?

Yes. Their bodies await resurrection.

I think we believe that only a few people who were assumed into heaven may have their resurrection bodies. But the passage in Thessalonians does not seem to distinguish between their body or soul being asleep.

This is simply phenomenological language, explained above. Jesus even seems to play around a little with this sort of language, when He described the daughter of Jairus, who had died: "Do not weep, for she is not dead, but sleeping" (Lk 8:52). Jesus then "prayed" both to the dead (by addressing a dead person) and for the dead (by commanding a dead person to return to earthly life), because He was talking to a dead child, and saying, "Child arise" (Lk 8:54). The next verse states "and her spirit returned," thus proving that it was separate from her body.

So what can I make of all this if anything? How do we answer someone who thinks that all the dead are still awaiting resurrection and to go to heaven therefore we can not pray to them?

I think I have shown various strong biblical arguments along those lines.

It seems they have at least a few Bible passages that seem to point to the idea that the dead are not in heaven but merely waiting in some other state.

Luke 16 about Lazarus and the rich man clearly teaches a third state.

I of course, accept whatever the church teaches, but I am curious how to best understand these passages.

I hope this has been helpful to you. For much more, see my web page:

Saints, Purgatory, & Penance


Maroun said...

Hi Brian .

I would like to quote a part of saint Augustine`s homelie on John 11:1-54.
"And after that He says unto them, Our friend Lazarus sleeps; but I go, that I may awake him out of sleep." It was true what He said. To his sisters he was dead, to the Lord he was asleep. He was dead to men, who could not raise him again; but the Lord aroused him with as great ease from the tomb as one arouses a sleeper from his bed. Hence it was in reference to His own power that He spoke of him as sleeping: for others also, who are dead, are frequently spoken of in Scripture as sleeping; as when the apostle says, "But I would not have you to be ignorant, brethren, concerning those who are asleep, that you sorrow not, even as others who have no hope." 1 Thessalonians 4:13 Therefore he also spoke of them as sleeping, because foretelling their resurrection. And so, all the dead are sleeping, both good and bad. But just as, in the case of those who sleep and waken day by day, there is a great difference as to what they severally see in their sleep: some experience pleasant dreams; others, dreams so frightful that the waking are afraid to fall asleep for fear of their recurrence: so every individual sleeps and wakens in circumstances peculiar to himself. And there is a difference as to the kind of custody one may be placed in, who is afterwards to be taken before the judge. For the kind of custody in which men are placed depends on the merits of the case: some are required to be guarded by lictors, an office humane and mild, and becoming a citizen; others are given up to subordinates; some, again, are sent to prison: and in the prison itself all are not thrust together into its lowest dungeons, but dealt with in proportion to the merits and superior gravity of the charges. As, then, there are different kinds of custody among those engaged in official life, so there are different kinds of custody for the dead, and differing merits in those who rise again. The beggar was taken into custody, so was the rich man: but the one into Abraham's bosom; the other, where he thirsted, and found not a drop of water. Luke 16:22-24

10. Therefore, to make this the occasion of instructing your Charity, all souls have, when they quit this world, their different receptions. The good have joy; the evil, torments. But when the resurrection takes place, both the joy of the good will be fuller and the torments of the wicked heavier, when they shall be tormented in the body. The holy patriarchs, prophets, apostles, martyrs, and good believers, have been received into peace; but all of them have still in the end to receive the fulfillment of the divine promises; for they have been promised also the resurrection of the flesh, the destruction of death, and eternal life with the angels. This we have all to receive together; for the rest, which is given immediately after death, every one, if worthy of it, receives when he dies. The patriarchs first received it— think only from what they rest; the prophets afterwards; more recently the apostles; still more lately the holy martyrs, and day by day the good and faithful. Thus some have now been in that rest for long, some not so long; others for fewer years, and others whose entrance therein is still less than recent. But when they shall wake from this sleep, they shall all together receive the fulfillment of the promise.

Maroun said...

Hi Brian .

Part two .
First he explains why the dead are called sleeping in the bible . Because our Lord can raise a dead person more easyer than we could wake a sleeping person .So the same person could be called dead ( for us ) and sleeping ( for the Lord ) .
The about praying to saints and the saints praying for us and so on . If you remember that in the bible , whether old or new testament , many many times , angels appeared to many prophets and also in the new testament , many times angels appeared and spoke with Zachariah for example , with the blessed virgin Mary , with our Lord Jesus Christ Himself in Ghetsemany . And also after the resurrection of our Lord , angels appeared and spoke with Simon Peter , with Philip , with John...In fact most of the times it was an angel speaking with John in the apocalypse ( book of revelation ). Now If the angels know what is hapening on earth ( in fact our Lord Jesus who is the truth and never lie said so , when he said that the children`s angels always see the face of God ) and also there is joy in heaven over one repented sinner more than 99 who did not need too ) and so on. Now , we are promised that we will be like angels in heaven , and our God disputing with those which denied the resurrection of the dead , said that God is the God of Abraham the God of Isaac and the God of Jacob , now He is the God of the living not of the dead .
So 1-angels know what is hapening on earth . 2-Angels do appear to people and speak and listen to them . 3-we will be like angels . 4-the saints are alive not dead . 5-Abraham knew exactly what was hapening on earth . 6-Moses and Elijah appeared with our Lord during the transfiguration . 7-all the verses which Dave quoted for you from the old and new testament .8-We are all members of the one body of Christ which is the Church . 9-if one members suffers the whole body suffers with it , if one body is glorified the whole body rejoices . 10-Love is stronger than death , the only reason why the saints are saints is because of their faith hope and love and the greatest of all is love which will be forever .
I could continue but i have said enough on the communion of saints .

Now about soul sleeping and so on . Here again ( and Dave could correct me or criticise me on this if i am wrong plz ) when we speak about those which departed from this life to the next , we must always remember something very very important . We exist in time , heaven and hell are in eternity. Eternity means timeless and endless . So from our point of vue , resurrection and judgement will take place in the future , but for those which are in eternity , everything is now for them . this is how we can understand and explain 1 Thess and 1 Cor 15 and so on .I dont think that i can explain this thing more than i did . At least i hope that i did not cause you to be more confused than before and GOD BLESS YOU .

Celestino Culaba said...

Good day sir, I consider myself fortunate to find your blogger and read some of your articles that help strengthened my catholic faith. Here in the Philippines there were about thousand of religious sect existing and lately this has already taken its toll in dwindle the number of our congregation in our area.
Through the effort of our parish priest and some close friends we came up of the idea to establish a devotion of praying the Holy Rosary and the rosary chaplet of the Divine Mercy. And lately as I have observed the effort produces good result of acceptance.
We have been guided of three words: Pray, listen and learn the formula left to us by father Rey to be our pattern every time we met once a week on Tuesday. The first word has already been addressed through the prayer of the Rosary and the devotion to the Divine Mercy but listen is somewhat in a level of competence we fall short unless we come up of a good speaker among ourselves and then learning follows. I believe it is through listening we learn the words of God.
The last meeting we had last Tuesday I have been given the opportunity to share some of my thoughts about our faith and belief to our catholic teaching especially of the rosary and the Divine Mercy, though, I admit I ended poorly in expressing my faith nevertheless I find it a good opening to learn more by reading several interesting topic from your articles.
I wish in a future with God’s grace I may send you copy of what I learned from my reading and consult you first before I expound it to my listeners. In that way I may be able avoid talking nonsense or lest I may be accused of heresy. I will always subject myself to the authority of the Church (Catholic) and I find you sir if you don’t mind to be my spiritual consultant.
Your brother in Christ Jesus!

Dave Armstrong said...

Hi Celestino,

I commend you for your efforts in strengthening and sharing your faith. I could look over something you write if it isn't too long, but I only have so much time for correspondence, and have to stick mostly to my writing.

If I answered at length all the letters I receive I would do nothing else; but I have to make a living, so that is my dilemma.

God bless you!


Joshua D. Hunter said...

MATTHEW 10:28 And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.

How can souls be immortal if they can be destroyed?

Dave Armstrong said...

The Greek word there, "apollumi" doesn't mean "annihilation." Rather, it means, according to Vine's Expository Dictionary of NT Words, "ruin, loss, not of being, but of well-being."