"Traditionalists": Catholic Quasi-Schismatics (Index Page)

Thursday, November 09, 2006


St. Joseph's Church, Detroit, MI: a traditional Novus Ordo parish

The history of Christian doctrine is . . . an avenue into the authentic continuity of Christian believing, teaching, and confessing. Tradition is the living faith of the dead; traditionalism is the dead faith of the living.

(Jaroslav Pelikan, The Christian Tradition: A History of the Development of Doctrine: vol. 1 of 5: The Emergence of the Catholic Tradition (100-600), Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1971, 9)



The image “http://www.chnetwork.org/images/logosmal.GIF” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.

http://ninevehscrossing.com/index.html

Syllabus of 60 "Traditionalist" Errors, Fallacies, and False Principles

Critique of my Syllabus of 60 "Traditionalist" Errors and My Counter-Reply (Dave Armstrong vs. Mark Cameron)

On Supposed Deficiencies in My Treatment of Radical Catholic "Traditionalists"

Dietrich von Hildebrand and Legitimate Catholic Traditionalism

My "Second Catholic Conversion": A Reductio ad Absurdum of So-Called Catholic "Traditionalism"

"Traditionalist" Catholic Attacks on Pope John Paul II: Accusations of Incompetence, Modernism, Compromise, and Heresy

Pope Benedict XVI (as Cardinal Ratzinger): Vatican II Has the Same Authority as Trent (if one goes, both go)

Pensées on Catholic Traditionalism by Dave Armstrong (Book) in Christianity



Purchase: paperback or PDF E-book ($3.00)



Purchase paperback from amazon.com

PDF / Adobe or Word 2000

The image “http://ic.net/%7Eerasmus/Library.jpg” cannot be displayed, because it contains errors.

11 e-books. . . Nope, Now 12 e-books (including this one) for only $15

[PDF^] [WORD^]


The "Traditionalist" Pet Term Neo-Catholic: Where Does it Come From? What Does it Mean?

"Traditionalist" Errors of the Seattle Catholic Documented

Are All Catholic Laymen and Non-Theologians Qualified to Freely and Frequently Criticize the Pope's Opinions and Prudential Judgment? (Dave Armstrong vs. Mario Derksen)

Critique of The Remnant, with Copious Documentation (Dave Armstrong vs. John Vennari, Michael J. Matt, etc.)

Dialogue on The Remnant ("Traditionalist" Group) (Dave Armstrong vs. Mark Cameron)



Dialogue: Catholic "Traditionalism": the Dreadful Malady of the Mind and Scourge of an Optimistic Faith in God's Protection of His Church (Dave Armstrong vs. David Palm and Mario Derksen)

Mark Shea, Sherry Weddell, & Yours Truly on Catholic "Traditionalism"

Radical Catholic "Traditionalism" vs. Optimism and the Indefectibility of the Church (+ Discussion) (Dave Armstrong vs. Ben Douglass)

Pope John Paul II's Teaching Concerning Marital Submission: Consistent Development or Contradictory Innovation? (+ Discussion) (Dave Armstrong vs. Ben Douglass)

Dissident Catholics and Catholic Doctrinal Unity: A Contradiction? (+ Matatics, Catholic Answers, Etc.) (+ Discussion)

Gerry Matatics Has Gone Completely (Theologically) Nuts (+ Discussion)

Critique of Some Comments From "Traditionalist" Ryan Grant (aka "Athanasius") (+ Discussion)

Is It Dissent Against the Pope and the Church, and Downright Disobedient For a Catholic to Favor the War in Iraq? (+ Discussion)

Last updated on 3 May 2008

12:01 AM :: permalink :: ::


navigation

  • http://socrates58.blogspot.com/2007/10/topical-index-pages.html
  • Topical Index Pages

  • http://socrates58.blogspot.com/
  • Current Front Page ("Home")

    • recent posts & comments

    Calvin, Calvinism, & General Protestantism (Index ...
    Newman, Chesterton, Lewis, & Romantic Theology (In...
    Liberal Theology & Modernism (Index Page)
    Conversion & Converts (Catholic) (Index Page)
    Inquisition, Crusades, & "Catholic Scandals" (Inde...
    Orthodoxy, Eastern (Index Page)
    The Church (Index Page)
    Trinitarianism & Christology (Index Page)
    Salvation, Justification, & "Faith Alone" (Index P...
    The Bible: Sola Scriptura (Index Page)

    blog search engine

  • LINK to Customized Google Search Engine

    • my books: info + purchase icons

  • http://store.payloadz.com/str-asp-i.72157-n.11_Catholic_Apologetic_PDF_E-Books_by_Dave_Armstrong__eBooks_-end-detail.html
  • 12 PDF E-Books for $15 (Info-Page / Automatic Download)
  • http://store.payloadz.com/str-asp-i.72168-n.11_Catholic_Apologetic_Word_2000_E-Books_by_Dave_Armstrong_eBooks_-end-detail.html
  • 12 Word E-Books: $15 (Info-Page / Automatic Download)
    • Martin Luther: Catholic Critical Analysis and Praise
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    The One-Minute Apologist
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    A Biblical Defense of Catholicism
    (^ Info-Page ^)
  • Word 2000 "Deluxe" Hyper-Linked Version ($5.00)
  • http://payloadz.com/go/sip?id=361608&aff_id=3924
  • PDF / Adobe Version ($5.00)
    • The Catholic Verses: 95 Bible Passages That Confound Protestants
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    The Church Fathers Were Catholic: Patristic Evidences for Catholicism
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    More Biblical Evidence for Catholicism
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    Bible Conversations: Catholic-Protestant Dialogues on the Bible, Tradition, & Salvation
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    Mere Christian Apologetics
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    Development of Catholic Doctrine: Evolution,
    Revolution, or an Organic Process?
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    Orthodoxy and Catholicism: A Comparison
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    Christian Worldview vs. Postmodernism
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    Pensées on Catholic Traditionalism
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    Twin Scourges: Thoughts on Anti-Catholicism & Theological Liberalism
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    Family Matters: Catholic Theology of the Family
    (^ Info-Page ^)
    Protestantism: Critical Reflections of an Ecumenical Catholic
    (^ Info-Page ^)
  • Please Consider a Donation For This Apostolate
  • My Online Catholic Bookstore (automated downloads)
  • PDF / Adobe Automated Download: 12-Book Deal
  • Word 2000 Automated Download 12-Book Deal
  • A Biblical Defense of Catholicism: PDF Download ($5.00)
  • A Biblical Defense of Catholicism: Hyper-Linked Word 2000 "Deluxe" Version Download ($5.00)

  • The One-Minute Apologist: Source Documentation for End-of-Section Quotations, Plus Additional Contexts

  • Are My Books Difficult or Easy to Read? An Objective Standard To Determine Relative Readability and Complexity / Comparison With Other Authors

  • My Lulu Author Page
  • My Sophia Institute Press Author Page
  • My amazon.com Author Page
  • Amazon Top 100 Bestsellers: Catholic Theology
  • Amazon Top 100 Bestsellers: Christian Apologetics

    • personal stuff


    icons













    catholic apologetics

  • This is the Faith Database (thousands of cross-referenced sources)
  • The Holy See (Vatican website)
  • The Catechism of the Catholic Church (second edition / searchable)
  • 30+ Catholic Radio Stations: Live Internet Streaming
  • The Coming Home Network (Marcus Grodi)
  • Evangelical Catholic Apologetics (Phil Porvaznik)
  • Catholic Audio Files (mp3) (compiled by Phil Porvaznik))
  • Ave Maria Radio (live streaming shows, incl. Kresta in the Afternoon)
  • Hands On Apologetics / Thy Faith, Inc. (Gary Michuta)
  • Sacramentum Vitae (Dr. Michael Liccione)
  • phatcatholic apologetics (Nick Hardesty)
  • Were Our Hearts Not Burning? (Fr. Paul Ward)
  • Crimson Catholic (Jonathan Prejean)
  • Catholic Answers (Karl Keating)
  • ScottHahn.com
  • The Official Peter Kreeft Site
  • Patrick Madrid: Apologetic Resources
  • AskACatholic.com (Mike Humphrey)
  • Right Reason (Dr. Francis Beckwith, Dr. Alex Pruss & others)
  • francisbeckwith.com
  • Cor Unum (Joe Gallegos; Church Fathers site)
  • Catholic Analysis (Oswald Sobrino)
  • InsideCatholic.com
  • Carl E. Olson Home Page
  • Ignatius Scoop
  • Ignatius Insight
  • Steve Ray's Blog
  • Against the Grain (Chris Blosser)
  • Musings of a Pertinacious Papist
  • The Fifth Column (Steve Kellmeyer)
  • The Way of the Fathers (Mike Aquilina)
  • Shrine of the Holy Whapping
  • The Curt Jester
  • Dyspeptic Mutterings (Dale Price)
  • Purify Your Bride (Randy Gritter)
  • Opinionated Catholic
  • Fides, Cogitatio, Actio
  • Cordelia's Shoes (Scott Waddell)
  • Dappled Things
  • Vivificat! A Catholic Blog of Commentary and Opinion
  • Kristine L. Franklin
  • In Toon With the World
  • Veritas
  • Sherry Weddell's writings at Catherine of Siena Institute
  • Laudem Gloriae
  • Crowhill.net (Greg Krehbiel)
  • Thoughts of Apolonio Latar III
  • Deo Omnis Gloria
  • Air Maria (Franciscans)
  • Catholic Friends of Israel
  • My Domestic Church
  • Meandering Home
  • Apostolate for Catholic Truth
  • CatholicBlogs.com
  • minion of the pope
  • Chad is Not Enough
  • Affirmation: The Fifth Love
  • The God Fearin' Forum
  • Articuli Fidei (David Waltz)
  • Pontifications (Fr. Al Kimel; inactive, but a fabulous archive)
  • Cathopologist
  • What Trouble Are Giants?
  • Disciple of the Dumb Ox
  • Carmelite Spirituality
  • Canterbury Tales (Taylor Marshall)
  • The Bride and the Dragon (Stephen Hand)
  • La Nouvelle Théologie
  • Principium Unitatis (Bryan Cross)
  • Recta Ratio
  • Stephen Korsman
  • Totus Tuus Ministries
  • 100% Catholic (John D'Arcy)
  • Cnytr (Lauren)
  • Room With a View
  • Eclectic Amateur
  • Catholic CD of the Month
  • Catholic Exchange
  • American Catholic Truth Society (Scott Windsor)
  • Andrew Apologetic Ministries
  • Another Sort of Learning (James V. Schall, S.J.)
  • Apologetics: Transporter Info. Services (Steve Clifford)
  • Apologia (Cat Clark)
  • Augustine Club Apologetics Toolkit
  • Catholic Apologetics Network
  • Et Cum Spiritu Tuo: Catholic Apologetics on the Internet
  • Catholic Biblical Apologetics (Paul Flanagan & Robert Schihl)
  • Catholic Bridge (David MacDonald)
  • Catholic Evangelism (Frederick Pogorzelski)
  • The Catholic Legate (John Pacheco, Frank Jerry et al)
  • The Catholic Treasure Chest (Bob Stanley)
  • Christendom Awake (Fr. Aidan Nichols & other orthodox Catholic scholars)
  • Catholic Culture: Website Reviews
  • The Crossroads Initiative (Dr. Marcellino D'Ambrosio)
  • Defending the Bride (John Hellman)
  • Catholic-View.com (Stephen P. Haws)
  • Dr. Robert Fastiggi (collection of articles)
  • In Defense of the Roman Catholic Church (Chris Tesch)
  • CanonLaw.Info (Dr. Edward Peters)
  • The Internet Padre (Fr. Ron Vierling)
  • "Matt1618's" Catholic Apologetics Page
  • The Roman Theological Forum (Fr. Brian W. Harrison et al)
  • JesseRomero.com
  • Scripture Catholic (John Salza)
  • Sean's Faith (Sean Hyland)
  • Simple Catholicism (Fr. Phil Bloom)
  • Second Exodus (Hebrew Catholicism) (Marty Barrack)
  • Catholic and Enjoying It (Mark P. Shea: great apologetics; beware of uncharitable political rhetoric)
  • Annunciations (Michael Dubruiel)
  • Charlotte Was Both (Amy Welborn)
  • Catholic Apologetics Page ("Matt 1618")
  • EWTN Document Library
  • EWTN Audio Library
  • Catechetics Online
  • American Papist (Thomas Peters)
  • The Supplement - St. Thomas Aquinas, Pray For Us
  • An Examined Life (Dr. Scott Carson)
  • Canon Law.Info (Dr. Edward Peters)
  • My Domestic Church
  • This Catholic Journey (Amber)
  • The Cross Reference (Jeff Pinyan)
  • Crossed the Tiber
  • RECONnecting to the TRUTH
  • Syzygus

    • lutheran