Sunday, May 23, 2004

Biblical Evidence for Annulments

From my notes for The Catholic Answer Bible (Huntington, IN: Our Sunday Visitor, 2002):
The Catholic Church teaches that a valid, sacramental marriage between two baptized Christians is permanent, or indissoluble. No power on earth can dissolve it. This is based on the explicit teaching of Jesus. In the passage where Jesus states “unless the marriage is unlawful” (Mt 19:9), Catholics believe He was referring to a situation where a marriage was never actually entered into in the first place. Matthew 19:6 states: “So they are no longer two, but one flesh. Therefore, what God has joined together, no human being must separate.” For this reason, the Catholic Church opposes divorce. An annulment is not merely a “Catholic divorce,” but rather, a declaration by the Church that a valid, sacramental marriage was never present (because several conditions must be met for this to occur: e.g., free will, truthfulness, mental health, etc.). A similar distinction is found in civil law across the entire Christian world. The Old Testament dichotomy between a concubine and a wife is somewhat analogous to our distinction between civil and sacramental marriage (Gen 21:10-14, Jud 8:31, 1 Cor 7:15). Likewise, in Ezra 10:1-19,44 (cf. 9:1-2,14-15), many Israelites “sent away” the “foreign women” they had married, not simply because they were foreigners, but because they caused them to become corrupted by false religions and idolatry (see. e.g., Dt 17:17, Neh 13:23-28). This was essentially an annulment, as opposed to a divorce.

Related Scripture

Gen 1:26-31
Gen 2:18-25
Gen 17:15-21
Gen 21:12-20
Mal 2:14 ff.
Mt 5:31-32
Mt 19:1-9
Mk 10:2-11
Lk 16:18
Rom 7:2-3
1 Cor 7:1-24
1 Cor 7:39
Gal 4:21-31
Eph 5:2,21-33
Heb 13:4
1 Pet 3:1-9

Catechism of the Catholic Church: 1534-1535, 1601-1666 (especially 1629, 1650-1651), 2382-2386
Related reading:

Dialogue: Annulment vs. Divorce

Divorce: Early Church Teaching


don_simoun said...

Thank you so much for this! I recognize that the Church allows annulment, but it is only now that I discovered the biblical background of this. :)

Dave Armstrong said...

You're welcome! Glad you like it.

Mark said...

Don't you thing the Church at times plays fast and loose w/annulments?

Dave Armstrong said...

Sometimes there have been abuses, yes. But in a recent discussion on Facebook on this, I noted that regardless of how often abuses occur, it's also true that people have less and less notion of what a sacramental marriage entails: thus leading to more annulments, because the ones granted an annulment never entered into it with a proper understanding of the commitments from the start.